1 / 25

For Sale · Tay (Port McNicoll)

$899,900

58 METHODIST ISLAND, Tay (Port McNicoll)

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

About This Home

The details.

A Lake Joseph inspired, finished property on the big waters of Georgian Bay. Enjoy the best boating, fishing, swimming and exploring the 30,000 islands of Georgian Bay. Travel by boat to the local restaurants or supermarkets and enjoy the water lifestyle and beauty of the ever changing landscapes. A rare beachfront property that is shallow and ideal for families. Just 5 minutes from the marina that has a pool, your...

Summarizing the highlights...

MLS® S13588020Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.View on map

Property Details

Facts & features.

Property type: Single Family
Ownership: Freehold
Storeys: 1
Listed on: 2026-07-21
Days on market: 1
MLS number: S13588020
Data source: Toronto Regional Real Estate Board

Market intelligence

Statistics and history.

Days on market

Tay (Port McNicoll) median asking

$650K

12 active listings

New this week

12 active listings

Where this price sits in Tay (Port McNicoll)

$120KThis listing$1.7M

Computed live from active MLS listings we track. Sold-price history and multi-year assessment history switch on when sold-data access arrives.

Coming Soon

Listing & sold history.

These sections unlock with our sold-data feed. They are reserved here so you know exactly what is on the way.

Sold history for this homeComing soon

Listing history (every time it hit the market)Coming soon

Days-on-market trend for this areaComing soon

Nearby sold comparisonsComing soon

July Value

What this home is worth.

Calculating a July Value estimate...

Run The Numbers

Mortgage and cash flow

Mortgage calculator.

Home priceDown payment20%Rate (%)Amortization25 yr

Monthly mortgage payment

$4,209

$719,920 financed over 25 years at 5%. For guidance only, not a quote or approval.

Cash flow analysis.

Property tax / moMaintenance / moRental income / mo

Monthly cost (mortgage + tax + maintenance)

$4,209

Cash flow

-$4,209

Estimates for education only. Talk to a JULY advisor for real numbers on this home.

Tay (Port McNicoll) right now

Active listings

New this week

$649,900

Median asking price

Live snapshot from the MLS® feed. Sold-price history and trend charts arrive with our VOW data feed.

The Neighbourhood

Living in Tay (Port McNicoll).

Household and demographic stats for Tay (Port McNicoll), from the Statistics Canada 2021 Census.

11,091
Population (2021): 49.2
Median age: 4,535
Households: 2.4
Avg household size: 90.4%
Home ownership: $82,000
Median household income

Tay (Port McNicoll) market trends

Source: Statistics Canada 2021 Census, Tay, Township, Ontario.

Similar homes

Nearby homes like this one.

Rental Market

Rentals nearby

Active rentals close to this home, for rent-versus-buy context and investors sizing up cash flow.

$2,700 / month
247 POPLAR AVENUE, Tay (Port McNicoll)
2 bed · 2 bath

My Notes

Track this home.

Write a note about this home

Contact JULY

Tour it, ask anything.

Reach JULY now

Call or text any time: JULY answers immediately, day or night, and can book this showing on the spot.

Call JULY Text JULY Email JULY

Talk to a JULY advisor.

Interested in this home?

Book a viewing with a JULY advisor.

Listing information is provided courtesy of the Canadian Real Estate Association's Data Distribution Facility (DDF®) and is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by JULY Realty or CREA. The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos identify professional services rendered by REALTOR® members of CREA to effect the purchase, sale and lease of real estate as part of a cooperative selling system. The trademarks REALTOR®, REALTORS® and the REALTOR® logo are controlled by CREA and identify real estate professionals who are members of CREA.